Reviewed by Shawn Zali, Co-Founder
Restaurants and bars are some of the most closely tested businesses in a California sales and use tax audit. They handle a lot of cash and tips, sell a mix of taxable and nontaxable items, and record sales on POS systems that don't always match the bank deposits or the tax return. The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) has a full chapter of its Audit Manual on bars and restaurants, and knowing what's in it takes a lot of the mystery out of an audit.
Our Co-Founder, Shawn Zali, spent 8 years as a CDTFA tax auditor. Here's what auditors focus on in restaurant audits, and what you can do about it.
1. Do your books, POS and returns agree?
Every audit starts with a basic comparison. According to CDTFA Publication 76, the auditor may compare:
- Total sales in your books to total sales reported on your sales tax returns
- Total sales in your books to sales reported on your income tax returns
- The tax you collected to the tax you reported
For restaurants, the auditor will usually also reconcile bank deposits to recorded sales. If your POS shows one number, the bank another, and the return a third, expect the audit to go deeper. Before fieldwork starts, run these reconciliations yourself so you can explain any differences, such as tips paid out, deposits from other income, or catering paid by check.
2. The credit card ratio
The credit card projection is one of the most common restaurant audit tools. The CDTFA's manual describes it this way:
- The auditor sets the percentage of credit card sales to total sales for a test period, either from an observation test or from daily sales records.
- They total your credit card deposits for the whole audit period from bank records.
- They divide those deposits by the credit card percentage to estimate total sales.
The manual tells auditors to consider adjustments for sales tax included, tips, and amounts withheld by card processors. These adjustments matter. If credit card tips aren't backed out, for example, they can inflate projected sales. So make sure every adjustment that applies to you is actually made.
3. Markup and the shelf test
If the auditor thinks your achieved markup (sales compared to cost of goods sold) looks too low, they may do a shelf test. The manual describes costing out your most popular menu items from purchase invoices, including "plate cost" items like sides, butter and sauces, then computing the markup for each item and for the menu as a whole.
A shelf test is only as good as its inputs. Pay attention to:
- Portion sizes and recipes. The manual asks the auditor to get these from you. Give accurate numbers, not guesses.
- Sales mix. Weighting matters. A high-markup appetizer shouldn't count as much as your best-selling entrée if it rarely sells.
- Cost of sales. The manual lists adjustments for self-consumed merchandise (including complimentary meals and hors d'oeuvres) and for pilferage and spoilage, and checks whether supplies are mixed into purchases.
- Bar versus kitchen. When bar and food sales or costs are mixed together, the manual warns that individual markups may not be representative, and that segregating sales or purchases may be needed.
4. Bars: pour cost and drink size
For bars, the manual covers pour cost percentage, drink sizes, free-hand versus jigger pouring, average pour tests, and allowances for overpouring and spillage, cocktails and specialty drinks, happy hour, special events, draft beer loss and bottled beer breakage. Each allowance changes the markup. If you run happy hour or pour generously by policy, document it with menus, price lists and written policies.
5. Observation (site) tests
An observation test is the physical observation and recording of your business's activity for a set time. The CDTFA's manual says:
- The auditor must complete form CDTFA-805, Observation Test Fact Sheet, before the test, ideally together with you.
- Test days should be representative and should avoid days right before or after a holiday when possible.
- A one-day test can be a preliminary check, but at least three full days are needed to project sales.
The fact sheet describes your hours, staffing, busy and slow days, and how you operate. Fill it out carefully. An unrepresentative test day can skew an entire audit period.
6. Taxable versus nontaxable food: the 80/80 rule
Whether cold to-go food is taxable at your restaurant depends on the "80/80 rule" in Regulation 1603. Generally, if more than 80% of your gross receipts come from food products, and more than 80% of your food sales are taxable (served on premises, hot prepared, and so on), then cold to-go food sold in a form suitable for eating on the premises is also taxable, unless you separately account for it with supporting records. The manual recommends a 90-day test period to evaluate this.
7. Employee meals, tips and comps
Auditors also look at how you handle employee meals, tips and self-consumed items. Keep written policies and records. Undocumented allowances are hard to defend.
What happens after the tests
When fieldwork wraps up, the auditor holds an exit conference to explain the findings. Publication 76 says auditors must give you copies of the audit working papers. If you disagree, you can give the auditor more information and then meet with the audit supervisor.
If the CDTFA finds you owe more, it mails a Notice of Determination. You generally have 30 days from the mailing date to file a petition for redetermination. See our guide: Got a CDTFA Notice of Determination? Your 30-day petition window explained.
A quick restaurant audit checklist
- Reconcile POS, bank deposits, sales tax returns and income tax returns for each quarter
- Pull purchase invoices for food, alcohol and supplies, kept separate where you can
- Write down recipes and portion sizes for your top-selling items
- Keep employee meal, comp and happy-hour policies in writing
- Keep tip records showing card tips paid out
- Make sure your POS keeps data for at least four years
- Decide who will be the contact. You can authorize a representative at the first call.
How Tax Resolution Plus can help
Shawn Zali spent 8 years as a CDTFA tax auditor. With our team of Enrolled Agents and CPAs, he helps restaurants and bars prepare for fieldwork, review test periods and shelf tests, check credit card projections, and file petitions and appeals. We can't promise any outcome, but we'll tell you plainly where you stand.
Learn more on our restaurant and bar audit page, meet our former CDTFA auditor, see our CDTFA sales tax audit help page, or read What to Expect in a CDTFA Sales Tax Audit.
Facing a CDTFA restaurant audit? Book a free 30-minute audit risk review or call (866) 900-9001.
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. CDTFA procedures change, so check the sources below for current details.
Sources
- CDTFA Publication 76, Audits: https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/formspubs/pub76.pdf
- CDTFA Audit Manual, Chapter 8, Bars and Restaurants (sections 0803, 0806, 0809.10, 0810.12, 0810.15, 0810.20, 0810.25, 0810.30): https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/taxes-and-fees/manuals/am-08.pdf
- CDTFA Publication 22, Dining and Beverage Industry: https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/formspubs/pub22.pdf
- CDTFA Tax Guide for Restaurant Owners: https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/industry/restaurant.htm
- CDTFA Publication 17, Appeals Procedures: https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/formspubs/pub17.pdf