Former CDTFA Auditor

Former CDTFA Auditor Defending California Businesses

Shawn Zali, Co-Founder of Tax Resolution Plus, spent 8 years as a tax auditor with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA). He knows how an audit is planned, how the tests are built, and what an auditor needs to see before changing a finding. Today he and our team of Enrolled Agents and CPAs use that knowledge on the business owner's side of the table.

Shawn Zali, Co-Founder of Tax Resolution Plus and former CDTFA tax auditor
Audits · Petitions · Appeals
Why it matters

Why it matters who sits across from the auditor

Most sales tax audits aren't decided by one big argument. They're decided by dozens of small choices: which quarters go into a test period, which records are accepted, how a sample is drawn, which allowances are given for spoilage or employee meals, and whether the final numbers pass a reasonableness check. Someone who has made those choices as an auditor knows where they can be questioned and what documentation actually moves them.

The process

How CDTFA audits actually work

The audit period and first contact

The CDTFA usually contacts you by phone first. The audit period is usually three years, you normally get two to three weeks to prepare, and you can have an authorized representative handle the audit from the first call. If there are significant delays, the auditor may ask you to sign a Waiver of Limitation, which extends the time the CDTFA has to bill you. Talk to us before you sign it.

Preliminary tests

The auditor typically starts by comparing:

  • Total sales in your books to sales reported on your sales tax returns
  • Total sales in your books to sales on your income tax returns
  • Tax you collected to tax you reported
  • Sales claimed as "for resale" to your resale customers

They may also check purchases of equipment and supplies made without tax, and test your achieved markup on cost.

Sampling

If the preliminary tests show possible errors, the auditor may review every transaction or use a sample. The CDTFA generally tries to use a statistical sample, where transactions are randomly selected and the results are projected across the period. If records don't support a statistical sample, another sampling method may be used. The auditor should discuss the sampling plan with you before finalizing it. That conversation is one of the most important moments in the audit.

Markup tests

When the CDTFA has a basis to question recorded sales, it can rebuild them from your purchases: cost of goods sold multiplied by a markup factor. The markup usually comes from a "shelf test" that compares your purchase costs to your selling prices. Every input matters: total purchases, how purchases are split between categories, allowances for theft, spoilage and self-consumption, and whether the test period is representative.

Observation (site) tests

For businesses like restaurants, bars and stores, the auditor may physically observe your business and record its sales for a set time, often to set a credit card-to-total sales ratio or a taxable percentage. The CDTFA's own manual requires a fact sheet completed with the business owner beforehand, and at least three full test days before results can be used to project sales. Test-day selection should avoid unusual days, such as those around holidays.

From audit to Notice of Determination to petition

  1. Exit conference. The auditor explains the findings, and you're entitled to copies of the audit working papers.
  2. Disagree before the report is final. You can provide more information, meet with the audit supervisor, and then with a CDTFA representative.
  3. Notice of Determination. If the CDTFA finds you owe more, it mails a Notice of Determination (the billing).
  4. Petition for redetermination: generally 30 days. You generally have 30 days from the date the notice was mailed to file a petition. Miss it, and the amount becomes final and due. Your remaining route is to pay and file a claim for refund.
  5. Appeals conference. CDTFA's Appeals Bureau holds an informal conference and issues a written decision.
  6. Office of Tax Appeals (OTA). If you disagree with the Appeals Bureau decision, you generally have 30 days from the date of the letter explaining your appeal options to ask for reconsideration or appeal to the OTA, an independent state agency.

Read more: CDTFA Sales Tax Audit: What to Expect · Got a Notice of Determination? Your 30-day window explained

Our review

What a former auditor looks for in your audit

  • Test periods that aren't representative: a holiday week, a remodel month, or a quarter with a one-time event
  • Sampling plans that were never discussed with you, or that mix unlike transactions
  • Markups built on incomplete purchase data or missing allowances for theft, spoilage, employee meals and complimentary items
  • Observation tests run on unusual days or with too few test days
  • Credits and exemptions that were left out, such as exempt food sales, sales for resale with valid certificates, and prepaid sales tax on fuel
  • Reasonableness checks: whether the projected sales make sense against your actual income
How we help

How Tax Resolution Plus helps

  • Act as your authorized representative with the CDTFA (CDTFA-392)
  • Review your records before fieldwork and fix gaps where we can
  • Work through sampling plans, markup tests and observation tests with the auditor
  • Prepare and file your petition for redetermination
  • Represent you at the appeals conference and, if needed, before the Office of Tax Appeals
  • Set up cleaner reporting going forward, including sales tax return filing and use tax

We can't promise any outcome. What we can promise is a clear read on where you stand and the deadlines that matter.

Industry pages: Gas stations · Restaurants and bars · Liquor and convenience stores

Book a free 30-minute audit risk review → · Call (866) 900-9001

Why Tax Resolution Plus

1,200+ clients helped · $68M+ recovered · BBB Accredited Business · 2021 BBB Torch Award

Former CDTFA auditor on our team

Our Co-Founder, Shawn Zali, spent 8 years as a CDTFA tax auditor. He knows how audits are planned and tested, and where findings can be questioned.

A team of Enrolled Agents and CPAs

Your audit is handled by people who work in tax every day. Our partner, Raman Zoobalan, has over 25 years of experience in accounting and tax resolution.

Serving all of California

Based in Irvine and helping business owners across California with CDTFA audits, petitions and appeals.

Book a free 30-minute audit risk review →

Common questions about working with a former CDTFA auditor

Straight answers about CDTFA audits and how we help.

Is Shawn Zali really a former CDTFA auditor?+
Yes. Shawn worked as a tax auditor at the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration for 8 years before co-founding Tax Resolution Plus. He now works only on the taxpayer's side.
Can you step in after the audit has already started?+
Yes. You can authorize a representative at any point. The earlier we're involved, the more we can shape test periods and sampling plans, but we also help at the exit conference, petition and appeal stages.
How long do I have to respond to a Notice of Determination?+
Generally 30 days from the date the notice was mailed to file a petition for redetermination. If you miss it, the amount becomes final, and your remaining option is generally to pay and file a timely claim for refund.
What is a markup test?+
It's a way for the CDTFA to estimate your sales from your purchases: cost of goods sold multiplied by a markup factor, usually built from a shelf test of your prices. It's used when the CDTFA has a basis to question your recorded sales.
Do I have to meet the auditor myself?+
Not necessarily. Your authorized representative can handle meetings and communication. The CDTFA does suggest owners consider attending the exit conference.
What does the free audit risk review cover?+
A 30-minute call to review your audit letter or notice, the deadlines that apply, and the main risk areas for your industry. It's not a guarantee of any result.

Related services and official resources

Got an audit letter, a call from an auditor, or a Notice of Determination? See how else we can help, or read the official guidance.

Book a free 30-minute audit risk review

Prefer email? info@taxresolutionplus.com · Phone: (866) 900-9001. No obligation. We'll call you within one business day.

Pick a time that works for you

Free 30-minute consultation with our team. No cost, no obligation.

Loading the scheduler. If it doesn't appear, call 866-900-9001 and we'll set it up together.