Reviewed by Shawn Zali, Co-Founder
A Notice of Determination from the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) is the bill that usually follows a sales and use tax audit. It lists the tax, penalties and interest the CDTFA says you owe. It also starts a short clock. If you want to dispute the amount, you generally have 30 days to act.
Our Co-Founder, Shawn Zali, spent 8 years as a CDTFA tax auditor. Here's what the 30-day window means, based on CDTFA Publication 17, Appeals Procedures, and the Office of Tax Appeals' own guidance.
What a Notice of Determination is
When an audit finds that you underpaid, or the CDTFA otherwise decides you owe more, it sends a billing. For most taxes and fees, that billing is called a Notice of Determination. It shows the tax or fee and penalty due, plus the interest that has built up.
If you don't agree, Publication 17 gives you two paths:
- File a petition for redetermination (an appeal), or
- Pay the amount and file a claim for refund.
The 30-day deadline
Publication 17 is direct about the timing:
- You generally have 30 days from the date the Notice of Determination was mailed to file a petition.
- The clock runs from the mailing date, not the date you opened the letter.
- You can't file early. An appeal filed before the Notice of Determination is issued isn't a valid petition.
- Miss the deadline, and the liability becomes final and is due. An appeal filed late is not a valid petition.
If you miss it, you still have a path: pay the amount determined and then file a timely claim for refund. For a payment made under a determination, Publication 17 says the claim deadline is generally the later of three years from the due date of the return for the period involved, or six months from the date the determination became final. That route means paying first, so it's far better to petition on time.
Different rules apply to a Notice of Jeopardy Determination. That notice is due on service, and Publication 17 gives you ten days to file a petition with a security deposit. Read your notice carefully and act right away.
What your petition must include
You don't need a special form. A letter works, or you can use CDTFA-416, Petition for Redetermination, or file online through your CDTFA account. Publication 17 says your petition should include your account number and must:
- Be in writing
- Identify the amounts you dispute, if known (you can dispute all or part)
- State the specific reasons you believe you don't owe it
- Be signed by you or your authorized representative
You can also:
- Request an appeals conference in the petition
- Ask to be considered for the CDTFA's Administrative Settlement Program. Publication 17 says settlement review is confidential and doesn't affect your appeal rights.
- Add grounds later. You can amend your petition with additional reasons while the appeal is pending.
Sales and use tax petitions can be emailed, faxed or mailed to the CDTFA's Petitions Section. The addresses are listed in Publication 17. Keep proof of when you sent it.
Tip from the auditor's side: "I disagree" isn't enough. The petitions that move forward explain specific problems, such as an unrepresentative test period, a sampling error, a markup built on incomplete purchases, or exemptions and credits that weren't allowed, and back them with documents.
What happens after you file
1. Review by the Business Tax and Fee Division (BTFD)
BTFD confirms it received your petition and may ask for evidence. It then sends you a letter with its conclusions. If it denies the petition in whole or in part, the letter may ask whether you want an appeals conference (or ask you to confirm an earlier request). Respond within 30 days. If you don't, a Notice of Redetermination will be issued.
2. The appeals conference
The CDTFA's Appeals Bureau holds an informal appeals conference. You'll get a Verification of Appeals Conference form to return within 15 days. The Notice of Appeals Conference is generally mailed at least 45 days before the conference. You can ask for expedited scheduling, for example by agreeing to attend in Sacramento or a Southern California office, or by phone. If you don't appear, the conference goes ahead without you.
3. The Appeals Bureau decision
After the conference, the Appeals Bureau issues a written decision. It may grant your appeal, deny it, grant it in part, or order a reaudit.
4. Your options after the decision
If you disagree, you generally have 30 days from the date of the letter explaining your appeal options to either:
- Ask the Appeals Bureau to reconsider, explaining why you disagree, or
- Appeal to the Office of Tax Appeals (OTA), an independent state agency
If you do neither in time, a Notice of Redetermination is issued based on the decision.
5. The Office of Tax Appeals
OTA appeals are generally filed through the Office of Tax Appeals Portal (OTAP), or by mail or fax, with a copy of the CDTFA's decision and your supporting documents. A three-member panel of administrative law judges issues a written opinion. If you disagree with it, OTA's rules allow a petition for rehearing within 30 days of the date the opinion is issued (mailed), on limited grounds. After the OTA process, further review generally means paying the tax, filing a claim for refund, and then going to Superior Court if the refund is denied.
6. Notice of Redetermination
At the end of the appeal, the CDTFA sends a Notice of Redetermination. If an amount is due, Publication 17 says you must pay it even if you still disagree. If it isn't paid by the time the notice becomes final (30 days after it's issued), a 10% penalty on the unpaid tax is added and interest keeps accruing.
A 30-day action plan
- Days 1–3: Find the mailing date on the notice. Count 30 days and put it on your calendar.
- Days 1–7: Gather the audit report, working papers, schedules and your records for the periods in question.
- Days 5–20: Identify specific errors and the documents that prove them.
- Day 25 at the latest: File the petition, with a request for an appeals conference, and keep proof of filing.
- Afterward: Answer every CDTFA and Appeals Bureau letter by its deadline.
How Tax Resolution Plus can help
Shawn Zali spent 8 years as a CDTFA tax auditor. With our team of Enrolled Agents and CPAs, he reviews audit working papers, prepares petitions for redetermination, and represents California businesses at appeals conferences and before the OTA. We can't promise any outcome, but we'll make sure your deadlines are met and your arguments are specific.
Learn more about CDTFA sales tax audit help, our former CDTFA auditor, and CDTFA sales tax refund claims. We also have audit guides for gas stations, restaurants and bars and liquor and convenience stores. New to audits? Start with What to Expect in a CDTFA Sales Tax Audit.
Got a Notice of Determination? Book a free 30-minute audit risk review today or call (866) 900-9001. The clock is already running.
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Deadlines depend on the exact notice you received. Always confirm against the notice and the sources below.
Sources
- CDTFA Publication 17, Appeals Procedures: Sales and Use Taxes and Special Taxes (Dec 2024): https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/formspubs/pub17.pdf
- CDTFA Publication 76, Audits: https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/formspubs/pub76.pdf
- Office of Tax Appeals, How to Appeal: https://ota.ca.gov/how-to-appeal/
- Office of Tax Appeals, Disagreeing with OTA (Apr 2025): https://ota.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/54/2025/04/Disagreeing-with-OTA.pdf
- Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18, § 30505 (Finality of OTA Opinions): https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/california/18-CCR-30505
- Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18, § 30602 (Time for Filing a Petition for Rehearing): https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/california/18-CCR-30602