Reviewed by Shawn Zali, Co-Founder
If you run a restaurant, bar, liquor store, convenience store, gas station market or other small retail business, you may hear the word "markup" in your California sales tax audit. A markup test lets the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) estimate what your sales should have been from what you bought. If the estimate is higher than what you reported, the difference can become an assessment.
Our Co-Founder, Shawn Zali, spent 8 years as a CDTFA tax auditor. Here's how markup tests work, based on the CDTFA's own Audit Manual, and where they most often need a second look.
The basic math
The idea is simple. The Audit Manual (Chapter 4) puts it this way: cost of goods sold multiplied by a markup factor equals sales. The markup factor is the markup percentage plus 100%. So if items costing $100 sell for $150, the markup is 50% and the factor is 1.50.
Markups can be used two ways:
- As a short test. The auditor compares the markup your records produce with what's reasonable for your type of business. If it looks reasonable, that can help support your reported sales.
- To establish sales. If the CDTFA has a basis to question your records, the auditor can compute audited sales by applying a markup to your cost of goods sold.
When can the CDTFA use the markup method?
According to Chapter 8 of the Audit Manual, the CDTFA's authority to question a taxpayer's records comes from Revenue and Taxation Code section 6481, and courts have upheld the markup method. The manual also says:
- The markup method may only be used when there is support that the taxpayer's records are inadequate, and the auditor must explain why your records were set aside.
- Even comprehensive records aren't automatically conclusive. But once the CDTFA establishes a deficiency, the burden shifts to you to explain the difference.
That's why the auditor's written explanation for setting aside your records is worth reading closely.
Step 1: Getting purchases right
The manual says a markup test "is only as reliable as the base from which the auditor is working," meaning your purchases or cost of goods sold. To verify total purchases, auditors may:
- Tie monthly or quarterly purchase totals to your records for the whole audit period
- Compare purchase invoices with what's on your shelves
- Review canceled checks, cash paid-outs and vendor statements
- If invoices seem incomplete, get purchase data directly from your vendors
Missing invoices hurt in two ways. They can suggest unrecorded purchases (and unreported sales), and they make the cost base unreliable. Pull complete vendor statements before the auditor asks.
Step 2: Separating purchases into groups
Different products carry very different markups. The manual tells auditors to separate purchases into groups with similar markups when possible, and to use a weighted average when they can't. Its examples include:
- Liquor stores: distilled spirits, beer, wine, soda, food, tobacco, newspapers and magazines, and other merchandise
- Service stations and garages: tires and tubes, oil, grease, parts, accessories, batteries and gasoline
If a low-markup category like cigarettes gets mixed in with high-markup snacks, the overall markup can be overstated. Check how your purchases were grouped.
Step 3: The shelf test
To set the markup for each group, the auditor usually performs a shelf test: comparing item costs from purchase invoices to your selling prices. For restaurants, Chapter 8 describes costing out your most popular dishes, including plate-cost items, using portion sizes and ingredients you provide. For bars, it covers pour sizes and drink prices.
Questions to ask about any shelf test:
- Were the prices current for the whole audit period? Prices measured today may be higher than what you charged two or three years ago.
- Were the items representative? A shelf test built on high-markup items will overstate sales if those items are a small share of what you sell.
- Was the weighting right? Each item's markup should count according to how much of it you actually sell.
- Were discounts, specials and promotions included? Happy hour, combo deals and vendor promotions reduce what you actually earned.
Step 4: Allowances that reduce the markup base
Not everything you buy gets sold at full price. Chapter 4 lists self-consumed merchandise, shrinkage of inventory, and inventory adjustments as items to consider, and Chapter 8 adds pilferage, spoilage, complimentary items, and alcohol used in cooking for restaurants and bars. Each allowance reduces the cost base before the markup is applied, so documented allowances matter.
Records that help: written comp and employee-meal policies, spoilage logs, theft or police reports, and inventory counts.
Step 5: The reasonableness check
When a markup analysis shows unreported sales, Chapter 8 says a reasonableness evaluation must be performed. The preferred method is to add the projected unreported sales to the net income on your income tax returns or financial statements. If the result is income your business clearly couldn't have earned, the markup deserves another look. The manual also lists bank deposit analysis, credit card projections, and gross profit and net worth analysis as alternative checks.
Exempt food: a special case
For liquor stores, smoke shops and similar businesses with a small amount of exempt food sales, Chapter 4 describes marking up the cost of exempt food items to test the food exemption you claimed. If the audited exempt food sales come out materially lower than your claim, the exemption may be reduced.
What you can do
- Keep complete purchase records and vendor statements for at least four years
- Track price changes over time (save menus and price lists)
- Write down your comp, employee-use and spoilage practices
- Ask the auditor to explain how purchases were grouped and how the shelf test was weighted
- Review the audit working papers. Publication 76 says auditors must give you copies.
If you disagree with the results, raise it with the auditor and the audit supervisor before the report is final. If a Notice of Determination is issued, you generally have 30 days from its mailing date to file a petition for redetermination. See Got a CDTFA Notice of Determination? Your 30-day petition window explained.
How Tax Resolution Plus can help
Shawn Zali has built markup tests from the auditor's side for 8 years. Together with our Enrolled Agents and CPAs, he reviews purchase totals, groupings, shelf tests, allowances and reasonableness checks, and represents businesses through petitions and appeals. We can't promise any outcome, but we'll show you exactly where the numbers came from.
See our pages for liquor and convenience stores, restaurants and bars and gas stations, meet our former CDTFA auditor, or see CDTFA sales tax audit help.
Questioning a markup in your CDTFA audit? Book a free 30-minute audit risk review or call (866) 900-9001.
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Check the sources below for current CDTFA procedures.
Sources
- CDTFA Audit Manual, Chapter 4, General Audit Procedures (sections 0407.10 Mark-Up Methods, 0407.12, 0407.15): https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/taxes-and-fees/manuals/am-04.pdf
- CDTFA Audit Manual, Chapter 8, Bars and Restaurants (sections 0803.05–0803.15, 0810.15–0810.25): https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/taxes-and-fees/manuals/am-08.pdf
- CDTFA Publication 76, Audits: https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/formspubs/pub76.pdf
- CDTFA Publication 17, Appeals Procedures: https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/formspubs/pub17.pdf